The War Room Report staff debates the most intrguing questions in our Hot Reads feature. This week we put our writers on the spot in our post draft edition.

1. Who is your early pick for 2007 Offensive Rookie of the Year?

Matt MacCoy, War Room Report Scout - I would normally vote for a Quarterback who is going to get significant playing time or a running back who would start from Day One due to the fact that the players at these positions touch the more most frequently. However, in the case of the 2007 NFL Draft class there is one offensive player who stands above the rest and will shine in the National Football League at that is Detroit Lions WR Calvin Johnson. If Mike Furrey can catch 100 passes in the Detroit Lion offense, what do you think this “super freak” is gonna do? Expect countless highlights and spectacular plays and expect him to be the 2007 Offensive Rookie of the Year.

Justin Davis, War Room Report College Writer - The 2007 NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year will be Robert Meachem, WR New Orleans Saints. Adding Meachem to an embarassment of riches of skill position players will make the Saints offense nearly impossible to defend. After watching Marques Colston’s transition from small college competition to the NFL last season, it doesn’t seem like too much of a reach to think that Meachem will step in with at least comparable production after dominating in the SEC last year. After dumping Joe Horn this offseason the second WR spot will be Meachem’s to lose going into training camp. A player with his physical tools will be a great complement to Drew Brees’ arsenal.

Rob Tribbett, War Room Report Editor - The offensive rookie of the year award is almost always won by a running back. Adrian Peterson is the top running back in the class, but he is likely to split time with Chester Taylor and plays on a team with a poor QB. Marshawn Lynch, despite being second in talent to Peterson, will be the 2007 Offensive Rookie of the Year. Lynch is a shifty back who can also catch passes out of the backfield. He will get the bulk of carries for the Bills who have a better offense than Minnesota. In the long run, Peterson will reign supreme, but if he can stay healthy, Lynch will be the big winner in 2007.

Chris Otwell, War Room Report Writer - Calvin Johnson…..I think that Calvin will get the ball an awful lot this year in Detroit as teams will continue to double team Roy Williams. Johnson has some pretty freakish physical abilities, and will be asked to step in and contribute right away.

Justin Moore, War Room Report Fantasy Writer - This early in the year, I am going to take Marshawn Lynch. There is no one impeding his progress to be the #1 back in Buffalo, and since he was drafted in the first round (12th overall), that pretty much solidifies the intentions of the Bills organization to let him gain all the yards on the ground for the next 5-7 years. Anthony Thomas is an excellent and reliable complement to Lynch’s running style, which will help to keep the rookie fresh all year. A slowly improving offense that was really only missing a play maker in the backfield will make this Lynch’s year.

2. Who is your early pick for 2007 Defensive Rookie of the Year?

Matt MacCoy - The NFL loves players who pressure the Quarterback and produce a high number of sacks. I believe the 2007 Defensive Rookie of the Year will come down to two players in similar situations– Pittsburgh Steelers Rookie OLB Lawrence Timmons and Dallas Cowboys Rookie OLB Anthony Spencer. The voting could be close, however, I am going to give the slight edge to Anthony Spencer. Spencer will be the primary beneficiary of playing opposite DeMarcus Ware in the Cowboys 3-4 scheme. Having Ware out there will not allow teams to focus their blocking scheme to Spencer’s side. Anthony Spencer is also playing for a media darling in the Dallas Cowboys, so he will get exposure for sure. He could produce double digits in sacks and snatch the 2007 Defensive Rookie of the Year.

Justin Davis - The 2007 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year will be Patrick Willis, ILB San Francisco 49ers. Willis was a tackling machine in the SEC with little help in front of or around him. On the newly revamped 49ers defense he is capable of even more. With all the additions this offseason at OLB, S, and CB they needed a playmaker in the middle and they’ve found their ideal fit in Willis. His football instincts and sideline to sideline speed give him the ability to be involved with nearly every play and impact the game each snap. The combination of his talent and the chance to play MLB for a Mike Nolan defense will make him the best defensive rookie this season.

Rob Tribbett - The 2007 Defensive Rookie of the Year will be Anthony Spencer of the Dallas Cowboys. Spencer is an explosive pass rusher that will produce the stat that voters love most - sacks. Spencer gets the opportunity to play across from DeMarcus Ware, a top speed rusher in his own right, and that should leave the rookie free to terrorize QBs. Spencer also will benefit from playing in the aggressive, blitz heavy system of Wade Phillips. Expect double digit sacks and a trophy for the former Purdue star.

Chris Otwell - Patrick Willis…..Same scenario with Patrick, with him stepping into a situation that he could start off the bat, and contribute heavily, makes quite a difference in SF.

Justin Moore - Defensive rookie of the year is a little harder to predict, where all your talent is not necessarily drafted in the first 50 picks. There was a lot of depth this year, with teams filling need slots in the 5th and 6th rounds. The consensus seems to be that LaRon Landry is the best defensive player out of the draft, but pairing him up with Sean Taylor only takes that much more focus off of him. The AP tends to pick linebackers for ROY, having chosen them 6 of the last 7 seasons. That being said, Patrick Willis, San Francisco’s pick at #11 overall will have the biggest impact on his new team. There are very few weaknesses in his game, and the few that exist can be corrected. SF is on the upswing again this year, this time from on the defensive side of the ball.

3. What team had the best draft in the 2007 NFL Draft?

Matt MacCoy - It is a close call this between several teams–the Detroit Lions, Atlanta Falcons, Carolina Panthers, and Minnesota Vikings all receive an ‘A’ from me upon review of their respective draft classes, but if I had to choose one above all the rest, I would have to choose the Minnesota Vikings. They got a stud RB with their first selection in Adrian Peterson, then followed up by getting an excellent WR prospect in Sidney Rice in Round 2. The Vikings continued to select excellent prospects when they addressed their defense in Rounds 3 and 4 when they selected CB Marcus McCauley and DE Brian Robinson. There were several times during the NFL Draft process where Peterson, Rice, and McCauley were all considered potential 1st round selections, and the Vikings drafted all three. They took another weapon for their young QB Tavaris Jackson, when they selected Aundrae Allison in Round 5 and got sensational value when they were able to pick Rufus Alexander in Round 6. All in all, it would be difficult for me to argue that any other team in the National Football League had a better draft then did the Minnesota Vikings.

Justin Davis - The best draft class of 2007 in my opinion was selected by the Carolina Panthers. After trading with the Jets, the Panthers were able to grab 4 of the top 36 players on our big board, all at positions of need. Beason and Jarrett should crack the starting lineup immediately while Kalil and Johnson should be in competition for a spot at the least. Just a great draft for a team that lost several close games after injuries to key starters early in the season. This draft class should reinforce the depth with quality young players needed to make a run into the playoffs.

Rob Tribbett - The best draft class was the Carolina Panthers. Carolina did a masterful job of trading back and still acquiring the player they targeted. While I am not as high on Beason as some others, he still should be an instant contributor. Dwayne Jarrett and Ryan Kalil both should start in 2007, with Jarrett an ideal fit next to deep threat Steve Smith. Charles Johnson does not play a position of immediate need, but concerns about Mike Rucker’s health could have him in the lineup sooner than expected. Johnson was a steal by the Panthers and has all of the tools to be a difference maker in the NFL. Ryne Robinson will make an impact as a return man and allow Smith to concentrate on being a receiver and second day picks Tim Shaw and Donte Rosario can also become starters. C.J. Wilson was a terrific value in the 7th round.

Chris Otwell - The Cleveland Browns……. Getting two top 10 picks in the first round was huge for the browns. Not only did they get a top rated QB, but they got the top rated LT to protect him. Those two together madeCleveland the highest rated team in the draft this year.

Justin Moore - Sticking with the San Francisco theme, from the standpoint of immediate impact, I feel the 49ers had the best draft. Potential DROY in Patrick Willis, Joe Staley immediately starting at OT, and by grabbing another starter at DE/DT with Ray McDonald with their 4th pick makes this draft class very good. While they could have passed on Jason Hill in the third round, everything else fell into place for them. Tarell Brown at 147th overall could end up being a great value pick if he is consistent and avoids injury. The other 4 picks will be suitable backups if they make the roster, and while not ranked very high, the Niners do need a solid RB option behind Frank Gore, so they took a flyer on Thomas Clayton.

Editor’s note: War Room Report Fantasy Writer Justin Moore debuts with his first article. The War Room Report features several top writers who have participated in and won very competitive leagues.

With the NFL draft all wrapped up, it’s time to jump on the train and start prognosticating about who is going to drive our fantasy teams to the promised land in 2007. We’ll start this year with an incredibly early list of who will contribute and who won’t to your team this year.

JaMarcus Russell – Oakland didn’t trade for Josh McCown for nothing. Even though he’s not very good, he’s going to start under center in September. By the time McCown loses his 6th or 7th game, look for Russell to start taking snaps to build rapport and timing with Mike Williams, Ronald Curry and maybe even Doug Gabriel.

Calvin Johnson – Jon Kitna gets the rock this year, while Drew Stanton learns. Don’t forget Roy Williams is no slouch and he and Kitna did pretty well together last year. With Tatum Bell, Kevin Jones, and TJ Duckett splitting carries, Detroit has the potential to have a rather significant offense this year, which Johnson will contribute to significantly, but with Mike Furrey still playing a role, don’t expect 1,000 yards from the rookie…this year.

Adrian Peterson – Fantasy ‘experts’ were all about Chester Taylor last year. Then some of them figured out he just couldn’t handle the load of a full season. With second year QB Tavaris Jackson likely winning the job out of camp, there will be a bit of a learning curve while everyone gels. Expect a RBBC to happen in Minnesota, and considering they’re not a particularly good team, Peterson isn’t much more than a flex player or 3rd RB.

Ted Ginn Jr. – Everyone’s talking about ‘the foot’. It’s already been said he’s not going to be ready for mini-camp. How long will this injury linger? With question marks all over Miami’s offense to include Daunte Culpepper, the possibility of signing Trent Green, Cleo Lemon, the drafting of John Beck, the possibility of losing Marty Booker, and Chris Chambers underachievement, this offense as a whole is probably the biggest question mark right now. If everything were to gel (which it won’t), Ginn would at best be the #2 WR, but more likely the #3 on this squad in his rookie year. If you draft him in your league, make sure it’s a late round and keep an eye out for any other WR who’s going to catch more than 600 yards and 4 TDs.

Marshawn Lynch – Lynch fell into a pretty good situation in Buffalo. As much as everyone loves to hate J.P. Losman, he finally started to figure it out in the second half of last year. He bonded with Lee Evans and threw more TDs (19) than INTs (14) to garner a passer rating around 85. Willis McGahee is out of town and Anthony Thomas is everyone’s fall-back when he needs to be. Lynch will probably be a 1st and 2nd down back with Thomas getting the conversion yards until the rook figures out the speed of the NFL and makes sure he can catch a few passes out of the backfield. If Buffalo continues to come together offensively, Lynch has ROY potential.

Brady Quinn – Everyone knows this kid got robbed on draft day. Miami stole his lunch money by not taking him at 9, and then Cleveland grinned and drafted him at 22, cutting his salary by 50% or more. Even with all the emotional fallout from that, Quinn could be the starting QB for the Browns on opening day. Charlie Frye and Derek Anderson are scrubs, and neither one of them is significant enough to learn from, so while the Browns start their rebuilding phase this year, Quinn should start all 16 games. Aside from Kellen Winslow, whose knee is still acting up, Braylon Edwards is the only reliable receiver. Jamal Lewis won’t do much better than he did in Baltimore last year, so expect Quinn to take his lumps with not enough help around him. I wouldn’t draft this guy in ANY format unless he was the last QB available and I needed to cover a bye.

Dwayne Bowe – There are still question marks as to who will be taking the snaps in KC this year. There are also rumors that LJ might get traded. That being said, Eddie Kennison can still put up decent numbers, so he’ll be fighting Samie Parker for the #2 slot here. If Trent Green isn’t still with the team this season, as expected, Bowe isn’t going to be of much use to anyone in 2007.

Robert Meachem – Joe Horn is out of town, so Marques Colston is now “officially” the guy in NO. The rest of the receiving corps fluctuates from week to week as far as production goes, and I see Meachem doing the same thing this year. Depending on how he comes out of preseason on the depth chart, he’s not going to be reliable enough to predict his 1 catch games vs his two 8 catch games he’ll have.

Craig Davis – Another tall, 200+ pound WR on a team that needs an identity at the position. The offense churns behind LT, and Philip Rivers sort of proved he is the man. I say sort of because they had one of the easiest schedules in the league last year. Since Parker and Jackson didn’t show much, Davis could have an opportunity to supplant Antonio Gates as the team’s top pass catcher. Unfortunately, that probably won’t happen this year. He’ll be a good late round pick to plug into a flex spot if you didn’t get that extra RB, but don’t count on him every week.

Greg Olsen – As long as Rex Grossman is in town, you never know what you’re going to get. Olsen is going to be one of those sexy pass catching TEs. That just means that with one less man on the line, Grossman is going to get hurried more, which will mean either Cedric Benson and/or Olsen is going to see an up tick on check-down passes. He’ll split time with Desmond Clark, and with the TE position getting deeper every year, this guy will probably get drafted by your fantasy opponents a lot sooner than he needs to.

Anthony Gonzalez – As long as Harrison and Wayne are still doing their thing, you can’t rely on a 3rd WR in Indy for any reason. That being said, if either one of them gets hurt for any amount of time, make sure Gonzalez is on your roster unless you’re stacked at WR.

Chris Henry – After losing Travis Henry, who kind of surprised everyone last year, question marks were all over Tennessee’s backfield. LenDale White seems like a has-been before he was ever any good. If he doesn’t get in shape and stop getting hurt, Henry could very well start right away. Unfortunately, with no WRs to speak of, defenses are going to key on Vince Young and whoever is in the backfield. Draft him as a keeper, but don’t be upset when 2007 isn’t his year.

Brian Leonard – Everyone seems to see a lot of skill in this guy, and I’m sure he has some, but with all those WRs and Steven Jackson learning to catch the ball last year, he’s not going to contribute to anyone’s fantasy team at all. Except that one random game where he’ll score 3TDs.

Paul Williams – He was drafted in the third round, and with no one of any significance at WR left in Tennessee, he could emerge as the #2 on that team, making him a minor sleeper.

Michael Bush – Another keeper league candidate. LaMont Jordan was so terrible last year, I almost went to Oakland to try to walk-on. They turned around and signed Dominic Rhodes in the off-season, and the starter will be whoever does better out of preseason and/or doesn’t get hurt. Michael Bush could sneak past one of those two on the depth chart and split carries all year behind the porous OL. Don’t expect much, though.

Antonio Pittman – Deuce and Reggie? Oh yea. Forget this guy until that game or three that Deuce has to sit out for some leg malady.

Brandon Jackson – Verand Morency isn’t very good. Neither are any of the other clowns the Packers have in the backfield. I wonder if they targeted Jackson in the second round or just missed out on the top tier guys, so they just took whatever was available in Round 2. They say he’s a bit small and not as fast as one would like, but if he gains some weight, he’ll be able to deal with all the hits he’s going to take in the NFL. He can also catch the ball a little bit, so this guy is going to be the one no one talks about because everyone thinks he’s a sleeper. Just because of the situation he’s in, he could end up being a top 3 rookie RB this year, but I’m not sure if he’s going to get 1,000 yards.

The Lions went ahead and selected Calvin Johnson, but the question remains if they will hold on to him. The Bucs still want him - Tampa is offering the 4th pick (Gaines Adams) and their 2nd and 3rd round picks for Johnson. I think there is a very realistic chance that this goes down. Brian Kelly may also be involved in the deal.

The Browns took Joe Thomas, over Brady Quinn and Adrian Peterson - this pick really impacts the Arizona Cardinals, who now may reach for Levi Brown at #5.

Quinn probably falls down to Miami now.

Barring any major developments, our final mock draft is posted. There are not too many large scale changes - the biggest occurs at #7 with Minnesota. We still believe that Miami will trade up to acquire Quinn and that the Bucs will find a way to get Calvin Johnson at #2.

One of the toughest projections in this version was actually for the Colts - if Justin Harrell, Lawrence Timmons, and Jon Beason are gone, where do they go? The popular commentary is cornerback, but in a Tampa 2 system, losing Nick Harper and Jason David is not a huge deal. It is important to remember that the Colts have former first round pick Marlin Jackson and a pair of 2nd round picks - Tim Jennings and Kelvin Hayden at the position as well. We went with Ben Grubbs for the selection as they could upgrade the OG position, which struggled at times in 2006, allowing defensive tackles to get to Peyton Manning.

Grubbs is not the only player to move up to Round One - Michigan ILB David Harris makes the move, thanks to New England’s love affair with him. He is a very good player and fits the New England scheme very well.

We have six players with Round One grades falling out of the round:

Dwayne Jarrett, WR, USC
Paul Posluszny, LB, Penn State
Jarvis Moss, DE, Florida
Justin Blalock, OG/OT, Texas
Sidney Rice, WR, South Carolina
Ryan Kalil, C, USC

As the draft approaches, the draft rumor mill is in full swing. Many of the rumors this time of year can be taken with a grain of salt. Yahoo Sports points out some of the more ludicrous rumors of recent years, including the rumor that Kevin Hardy had a broken neck that broke just days before the draft in 1996. Below are some of the rumors we are hearing and our take on them.

Adam Schefter of the NFL Network is speculating that Adrian Peterson could be a player that falls. In fact, if he gets past Cleveland at #3, he could go all the way to #10 with Houston. The Bucs have Cadillac Williams, Arizona has a large investment in Edgerrin James, and Washington has two strong RBs. Minnesota is projected to take Peterson in some mock drafts, but after the investment they made in Chester Taylor last season and the huge needs they have at CB and WR, it would be a foolish move. Atlanta could certainly consider Peterson if he is there. The Falcons do not have a running back to fit Bobby Petrino’s system and Peterson would certainly be interesting there. Miami is unlikely to take a QB, which would potentially put Houston in the position to auction off #10 to Buffalo (#12), Green Bay (#16), or Tennessee (#19).

A casual mention in the Denver Post of a possible trade up by the Broncos has garnered a lot of attention. The article states that Denver offered #21, #56, #86, plus their first rounder in 08 for the #2 pick currently owned by the Lions, provided that Calvin Johnson is still on the board at #2. While this sounds good, it still may not be enough. Plus, Denver is more likely to target other players - potentially Patrick Willis or Amobi Okoye, than Johnson.

Lance Briggs trade rumors still persist. The latest rumor is that the Tampa Bay Bucs are interested in the disgruntled Bears OLB. The reliable Adam Schefter reports the rumor, but it seems very unlikely. The Bucs already have a pair of weakside Tampa 2 OLBs in Cato June and Derrick Brooks. The Bucs trading for Briggs makes even less sense than the rumored Redskins deal for Briggs. It just goes to show that the rumor mill can get out of control this time of year.

Stay tuned to the War Room Report Blog for the latest NFL Draft Rumors and be sure to check out our seven round 2007 NFL Mock Draft.

The 2007 NFL Draft is fast approaching and this year could see an unprecedented number of trades. The needs of the teams at the top of the draft do not line up with the value of the players available. In addition, several of the top teams have multiple needs and few picks, so it would make sense for them to trade down.

Teams likely to trade down:

Detroit Lions - The Lions are likely to see Calvin Johnson on the board, but after recently spending 3 first rounders on WRs, with only Roy Williams to show for it, the Lions will be hesitant to pull the trigger. They need a player to pressure the QB to make the Tampa 2 scheme work and are reportedly in love with Gaines Adams. They should find no shortage of suitors for the pick, particularly if Johnson is available.

Washington Redskins - The Redskins have already tried to move out of this spot. The best move for the team, particularly if Adams is gone, would be to trade down to replace some of the picks they have lost in other trades. The Skins do not have a pick in rounds 2-4 and trading down slightly would help a team with several needs replace those needs and build for the future.

Minnesota Vikings - One of the best examples of a team whose needs do not fit the draft slot. The Vikings desperately need to add a cornerback or a wide receiver, but pick 7 is probably too high for Leon Hall or Ted Ginn. The Vikings would easily be able to make a trade out of the 7 spot if LaRon Landry was available.

Houston Texans - The Texans, like the Redskins, have a number of needs but not the necessary amount of picks to fill the spots. They traded their 2nd rounder in the Matt Schaub deal. Like the Vikings, they need to add a CB or a WR most of all, but may be better served by moving down slightly and targetting those two positions in the first 2 rounds.

Teams most likely to trade up:

Tampa Bay Bucs - The Bucs want Calvin Johnson and have the ammunition to make a move. Though it seems unlikely they will pay the price that Yahoo Sports has suggested (basically all of their picks) to move up to the #1 slot, if Oakland takes Russell, look for Tampa to move up to the #2 slot to add Johnson.

Atlanta Falcons - The Falcons may want Calvin Johnson too and the Lions may be able to start a bidding war. The Falcons, thanks to the Matt Schaub trade, have the ammo to move up to #2. If the Falcons decide they want Joe Thomas or LaRon Landry, they may choose to move up slightly to acquire one of those two players.

Denver Broncos - The Broncos have been very active in free agency and Mike Shanahan seems to think this team is ready to compete for the Super Bowl this year under second year QB Jay Cutler. The Broncos do not have a lot of needs, but the release of Al Wilson may make them players for Patrick Willis. The public statements that D.J. Williams will move to the MIKE linebacker spot could be a smokescreen from the calculating Shanahan.

With the news of the Matt Schaub trade to Houston, Atlanta now could very well trade up to target local product Calvin Johnson.

Johnson would be the perfect fit for owner Arthur Blank has he tries to sell tickets. Johnson would give Michael Vick the reliable target Atlanta has been searching for, as they have spent recent high picks on Roddy White and Michael Jenkins.

The likely trading partners would be Detroit and Cleveland. Both teams have many needs and a dealing allowing them to receive the #8, #39, and #44 picks would give them the opportunity to address many needs.

Foxsports.com is now reporting that the Texans gave up a lot more than originally thought for Matt Schaub. Houston gave up their 2007 2nd round pick, 2008 second round pick, and the #8 overall pick in the 2007 draft in exchange for Schaub and the #10 overall pick.

Houston is making a huge committment to Schaub here. Does this give Atlanta the ammunition to trade up for Calvin Johnson?

• Denver Broncos added tight end Daniel Graham from New England. Graham signed a five year, $30 million deal, with $15 million dollars guaranteed. It seems like a huge amount of money for a “block first” tight end on a team that already has a promising weapon at TE, Tony Scheffler, but the Broncos do run the two TE Set often, and appear to be really gunning up for a 2007 playoff run.
• Desperate times call for desperate measures. The Minnesota Vikings, who currently have first round bust Troy Williamson at the top of the depth chart, signed Bobby Wade of the Titans. Wade had 33 catches last year for Tennessee. The Titans have now lost two WR, at what was already a weak position. They will definitely be looking for a weapon early in the draft.
• In draft news, we are hearing rumors that the Raiders were less than impressed with JaMarcus Russell’s attitude at the combine. He showed up overweight and told teams that “he would lose it in a few weeks”. Troy Smith also showed up a few pounds heavy, but seemed more remorseful about it. Russell is still the favorite to go #1, but do not discount Calvin Johnson’s chance.

The St. Petersburg Times is reporting that top prospect Calvin Johnson recently ran a 4.33 40 yard dash and has a 43″ vertical leap. The Times reports that Tampa Bay could be interested in Johnson.
Johnson was already the #1 prospect on the WRR Board, further cements his position with these incredible numbers.