25th April 2007

2007 NFL Draft Quarterbacks

There are a lot of rumors floating around about who will be the 3rd quarterback selected in the 2007 NFL Draft, after JaMarcus Russell and Brady Quinn. Some rumor sites are even speculating that the third QB could sneak into the end of Round One (via a trade up).

While we are not sure who will be the 3rd QB drafted (Our money is on Trent Edwards), we know who it should be:

Drew Stanton.

Stanton has ideal size, outstanding arm strength, and is one of the better athletes at the position. He has a good release and the ability to make all of the NFL throws (which separates him from many of the other QBs). Stanton uses his athleticism to expand the pocket and can throw well on the run. He was one of the most accurate QBs in the country during his junior season, only to regress slightly in his senior season. The main concern with Stanton is consistency, but it is hard to judge him since he played on an over-matched Michigan State team.

But Stanton has the base to become a very good quarterback if developed properly. His high upside makes him a deserving #3 QB. He has been rated our 3rd highest QB all along and we see nothing that indicates we should change our ranking.

Many other sites change their rankings frequently in the off-season, which we do not understand. The rankings should not be based on public opinion, but what you think of each player. Some changes will occur, but drastic shifts should not happen frequently. We applaud those who maintain consistency and conviction in their rankings like The Huddle Report and Draft Daddy.

Some of the other QBs that are rising are interesting - John Beck of BYU and Kevin Kolb of Houston are mentioned as possible 3rd QBs selected (Along with Stanton and Edwards). Beck is an older prospect who is a better athlete than some think, but he has a thin build and an awkward release point. We question his upside - can he ever been better than an average starter?

We like Kolb, but the development curve may be high. He played in a version of the spread in college and will have to adjust to the NFL. He seems an ideal fit for a West Coast offense, and while his future potential seems high, he needs to develop a more consistent delivery and is going to be limited in the scheme he can play in.

It will be interesting to see who will be the third QB selected, but for the War Room Report, that is little doubt that Drew Stanton deserves to be.

posted in John Beck, Kevin Kolb, Drew Stanton, Trent Edwards, Rankings, 2007 NFL Draft | 2 Comments

21st March 2007

Trent Edwards Pro Day

Stanford QB Trent Edwards

 

 

Stanford QB Trent Edwards, a War Room Report favorite, had a solid workout for scouts on March 20th, reports Gil Brandt of NFL.com. Edwards was one of the top HS QB prospects, but struggled behind lackluster coaching, poor talent around him, and injuries at Stanford.

Edwards, who could be as high as the 3rd QB taken, completed 57 of the 60 passes he attempted. Several high profile offensive coordinators and quarterback coaches were in attendance. Edwards had a solid junior season playing for Stanford, throwing 17 TDs with a 63% completion rate. Edwards has all of the tools and the necessary size to become a solid NFL QB with the right coaching.

posted in Trent Edwards, Pro Day Results, 2007 NFL Draft | 4 Comments